📄
BA Q1 2023 Earnings Call
April 26, 2023 at 12:00 AM
🔍
Company
BA
Quarter
Q1 2023
Date
April 26, 2023 at 12:00 AM
Speakers
2
Word Count
~6,728
Transcript Content
Speaker
Dave, the quality slip or escape at Spirit, it sounds like it's been going on for several years actually. So I think the natural question we've been getting is, why did it take so long to discover? And how should we be comfortable that things like this won't continue to pop up, particularly with the FAA's sort of renewed zero tolerance for noncompliant deliveries? David Calhoun (CEO): Yes, Myles, I appreciate the question. This particular defect, I happen to take a look at it, by the way, along with the rest of my Board. We happen to have our shareholder meeting shortly after the issue came to our attention. It's not only a defect. It's in that app section of our airplane and very difficult to visibly assess. In fact, it's impossible to visibly assess once the process to do it is complete. So without witnessing firsthand that process in action, you're not likely to find it from that point forward. The process was not standard. And importantly, there was a ceiling that was applied on top of the fitting that made it impossible to notice any cracks. So it's just one of those. Again, no safety implications. The margins in our designs provide for significantly greater safety protection. So anyway, I don't ever accept and I hope you don't think we might ever accept that where these things go on, but this one, in particular, very, very difficult, no matter how many people you put in the field or that Spirit puts out there to see. Anyway, the good news is we've now been through the unveiling of the issue. We've been through the rework procedures, both on the captured fuselages in our factory that have not yet gone through the subsequent stages. And we've already looked at finished good airplanes where we have to remove the fin in order to get at it. And these are all now defined work scopes. And now we just get more efficient in the process of doing that reworking. That's why we're confident in our guidance. But again, we don't accept them. They are, without a doubt, over time, becoming more manageable. And things like this, I will celebrate the fact that an employee witnessed the procedure and raised his hand and said, 'That doesn't look right.' That is the only way that we would have ultimately found out about it. And I'm encouraging everybody in our supply chain, if they see something of that sort, to raise their hand.
Speaker
Maybe how do we think about BCA margins going forward? How do we think about the production trajectory of your impact, concessions historically in aircraft and inventory impacting BCA margins? Brian West (CFO): Yes. Thanks, Sheila, for the question. Broadly speaking, as we've said, margins will be a bit volatile this year and the next as we do a couple of big things. First, we got to liquidate the 37 and 87 inventory levels as well as shutting down those shadow factories. We also have to move through the abnormal expenses on the 87, the 777 and then prepare to ramp rates. So it will be a little up and down as we move through and get out and get out of next year. In terms of the near term, I did indicate last month that the first quarter BCA margins would be lower than fourth quarter, and that's for things like the abnormal and things like the lower volume. 2Q will also be negative. But as we move into the back half of the year, the margins will improve. And of course, as Dave mentioned, by the time we get to '25, '26, we still see a path to get BCA back to the double-digit margins that you all recognize. So we got to work through what's in front of us. It's clearly defined, and we just got to execute.
Speaker
On the 787, you're on the path to reach 5 a month in Q4 and then go to 10 a month in '25, '26. And you've also had some discussions that the rate could potentially go higher longer term. Now this is all being done in Charleston. And if we go back a few years, the maximum capacity at Charleston was 7 a month. So as you go to 10 per month there or higher, what do you need to do in terms of investment? And how would you expect margins for the 787 out of a single facility then compared to what they were before the downturn when you were operating out of both Everett and Charleston? David Calhoun (CEO): Let me begin by discussing the back end and then moving towards the front end. When transitioning from producing two units to one and optimizing that single unit without transporting parts between facilities, we anticipate an increase in margins, and I am confident we will realize that. Regarding investment, it primarily relates to how we manage routing within the factory rather than physical investments in equipment. Currently, our factory is somewhat limited due to the joint verification effort utilizing considerable space, both inside the factory and at our Everett facility. We need to work through these constraints. We have a dedicated team focusing on planning new routing strategies in the factories, and we believe we can achieve our target of 10 units. I am not concerned about significant investments needed to move from the noted capacity of 7 to 10 units; it will take time, and we need to eliminate the joint verification effort from our operations. Brian West (CFO): And Doug, as it turns to margin, on the program margin side, we fully expect by the '25, '26 timeframe to have 787 margins that are higher than they were back in '18. And it will be because of things like this consolidation to Charleston. And also on the cash front, on the unit margin perspective, 787 margins will get better on the improved -10 content as well as the benefits that Dave described of consolidating in Charleston. So we think we've got a good plan in front of us, and we are very focused on 10. 10's the number, and there's like execution that's underwriting that.
Speaker
Wanted to try to ask about the 737 pace in the near term and then also in the medium term between now and the plan you've outlined for '25. So I guess, how many units are somewhere in process somewhere in a factory? It seems like those need to be reworked before you could then restart to sort of clean off the line units. Brian, it sounds like the averaging 30 for the first 6 months, you kind of have implied second half of April as disrupted, May as maybe heavily disrupted, June starts to look normal again. Is that all correct? And then in the medium term, in terms of the ramp, there's some reputable press talking about this 38 being close to the middle of the year, wanting to be at 42 early in '24 and wanting to be at 52 early in '25. I guess we know the demand is there. In a scenario where the supply chain is relatively consistent, is that at least what you're working towards? Brian West (CFO): Yes. Let's begin with our plan to reach 38. We'll focus on that target without stressing about subsequent increases. We still aim for 50 in 2025 and 2026. In the short term, we are aware of the production details at Spirit's factory and our facility. For repairs on units that are not far along in production, it typically takes only a few days. However, fixing components like the vertical fin on an airplane is more complex and time-consuming. Nevertheless, we will navigate through this challenge. Restoring production to normal levels will take a few months. Regarding our inventory of 225 finished goods, about 75% will require modifications. The positive aspect is that this will not hinder our goal of liquidating the 737 inventory by the end of 2024, although it will incur additional costs, which we have already taken into account in our first-quarter projections. Overall, we feel confident about our path forward, collaborating closely with Spirit, and as we progress through this short-term recovery, we will work toward reaching the 38 target. It’s important to highlight that we have acknowledged this situation, and our master schedule remains unchanged, which is crucial for ensuring that the supply chain can keep up as we continue through the year. David Calhoun (CEO): Noah, regarding the finished goods, there are two key points to consider. First, we've largely completed a couple of them already, and we are defining the scope of that work, which is expected to be measured in weeks rather than months. Therefore, we are confident in our progress. Secondly, it's important to note that we have a significant conformance work scope even without the defect. Much of that work can proceed simultaneously, so it doesn't represent a total addition to our workload.
Speaker
The finished goods situation seems manageable as long as reworking can be done more quickly than delivering. The percentage of deliveries affected by this issue isn't significant, which makes sense. I wanted to understand the factory situation better, but I feel like I have a clearer picture now. I appreciate the additional insights.
Speaker
I have a quick clarification and then a question. The production rates you mentioned, the 38, is that specific to Renton? Or does it also include deliveries from inventory at Moses Lake and production from there on the modifications? My question is about the pricing environment, especially with competitors sold out on narrow-bodies and the 787 being in high demand on the wide-body side. How has the pricing been on these large recent orders, and what do you anticipate as we move forward? Brian West (CFO): You broke up a little bit at the end of your question on pricing. Could you just... David Calhoun (CEO): Yes. Let me comment on pricing, particularly in the wide-body market. Nobody is completely sold out; we're all selling further out. We still compete, and the actual deliveries are an important competitive factor, with pricing following that. The idea that the pricing environment is firming is likely a valid perspective. We don't discuss pricing during these calls except to indicate that as tight as the market is, both the timing of when you receive your airplane and the price itself matter. In every competitive situation, we all do what we need to do. I am very happy with the orders we've secured, and I’m sure Airbus feels the same way. Brian West (CFO): And in your clarification question, the first part, that 38 is the final assembly number. So right now, it's at 31, movement of 38 sometime later in the year.
Speaker
Just following up on the MAX issue. Has Spirit fixed the manufacturing issue from their end? In other words, are fuselages coming off their line clean now? And when would you actually start to expect to see those come to you? Brian West (CFO): They know the fix there, they know the scope, and they're going to start delivering clean ones imminently. So we feel good about what they've got to go do. Of course, the harder work is on our end for something that's in finished goods inventory.
Speaker
Okay. Quick follow-up, I think from the Investor Day, I recall the pacing item on going to 38 a month being activating the third line in Renton. Have you actually activated the third line at this point? Brian West (CFO): You bet. David Calhoun (CEO): And we're still moving forward on the fourth.
Speaker
Just a quick question on the outlook for orders in the commercial business. So wondering if you could kind of provide a little bit of color on your expectations from a book-to-bill perspective for the year, given the pipeline that you're seeing. And I don't want to get too far ahead of ourselves here, getting the MAX back up in the air and China is great. Deliveries are next. But I'd also be interested to get your thoughts on the future for deliveries in China specifically. David Calhoun (CEO): Yes. Let me begin. I want to clarify that all of our guidance and expectations are based on the assumption of no activity in China. Everything we have discussed regarding production rates, supply constraints, and demand does not include that factor, and I want to emphasize this. However, we are actively working to re-establish our presence in China. If we succeed, it will reduce the risks associated with delivering finished goods because there will be less work involved in getting the airplanes to their intended customers. That said, our production rates will remain unchanged, as we are already constrained by supply. These constraints are not driven by demand. I believe we could increase production significantly if the supply allowed for it. Regarding future orders, I can only say that each subsequent order, which are substantial and numerous right now, is resulting in even longer delivery timelines. We are currently looking at delivery timelines extending into the 30s, meaning our backlog is supporting deliveries over a much longer period, extending far into the future, potentially 5, 6, or even 7 years.
Speaker
At the November Investor Day, you laid out a forecast of cash flow of $3 billion to $5 billion this year. And since that time, you've taken a couple of shells, you see the 737, you discussed the 767, and you mentioned because of supply chain having to build to higher inventories. So there were a lot of bad guys in that revised number. What are the good guys to get you home to stay in that number? I know you had the $1 billion tanker advance, but are the advances from airline customers substantially better? What are the good things in that forecast that allow you to maintain it? David Calhoun (CEO): Cai, I want to start by reminding you that we always anticipated the tanker advance, which may have arrived a bit earlier due to the need for tankers in the field. However, we did not foresee the supply chain recovering so quickly without issues. When we provided our guidance, we made some judgments knowing we would have to navigate through various challenges. While a couple of those challenges turned out to be tougher than we initially expected, it wasn't much worse. This was all factored into our guidance, which will remain relevant through 2024. Brian, feel free to share insights on some specific aspects. Brian West (CFO): Yes, just a couple of things. Thanks for the question, Cai. On the first quarter, 787 deliveries were a little light. We'll make that back up in the rest of the year. You mentioned the tanker benefit. That's something that we always plan for later in the year. The customer just wanted to get it done a bit sooner, which we think is good. So that's the first quarter. And then in the second quarter, as I mentioned, we'll be in more of a breakeven position largely because of the 737s that are going to push out. But again, it's going to be back half benefit. In the second half, as I think about the acceleration, it's going to be the 737 recovery, the 737 rate ramp. And there's going to be wide-bodies that are going to accelerate across the board, 777, 787, 767. So all of that's contemplated. And we've still got high conviction along that range. High end might be a little bit pressured, but we're committed to delivering that commitment of $3 billion to $5 billion.
Speaker
Dave, I appreciate your comments on China. And I know you've derisked the skyline out through '26 on sort of deliveries, but seems like it's important steps that the regulator made. I'm just wondering whether you see this as that these next steps to delivery, is it customer-driven? Or is it still regulator-driven? How do you interpret that? David Calhoun (CEO): Yes. I want to clarify that the China market, which has always posed challenges for airplane deliveries, has returned more strongly than expected. Domestic travel has reached pre-pandemic levels and is likely to keep increasing, which means there is a demand for airplanes. I firmly believe that our customers will need more airplanes in the near to medium term, and this is a straightforward way for them to meet that demand. I don’t want to delve into any geopolitical discussions because they are unnecessary in this case. We have orders confirmed and airplanes ready, and the Chinese government’s recent signals indicate a desire to take delivery of those airplanes. That’s the current situation. I also want to maintain that our guidance and all activities will be based on the assumption that the most favorable scenarios may not occur. If they do, we will gladly welcome that news and keep you informed.
Speaker
Dave, I wonder if we just talk for a second about Spirit in a broader context. I think the current issue might even predate the grounding, but they've been struggling there on a couple of different fronts lately. And the idea of moving to 38 and then to 50 is you can only go as fast as they can go. And it's pretty understandable because I don't think anybody has had a more challenging 3 or 4 years than Spirit other than maybe you guys. But how are you going to make sure that they're there to support that rate increase for you maybe more broadly, and then with a specific reference to the big labor contract that they have coming up in June? David Calhoun (CEO): I remain optimistic about the labor contract. I believe the workers understand their situation and the need to deliver for Boeing, so I anticipate they'll reach an acceptable resolution. This matter is beyond my control, so you would need to refer to Tom for more details. I trust in their capability to increase production alongside us. We have been making steady progress to ensure they can keep up with our ramp rate, and they were making reasonable advancements. The recent defect will result in delays measured in weeks and months, but it won't hinder their ability to meet our production increases. We will maintain our presence with Spirit, engaging directly in their factories and conversations. As I mentioned, there are different perspectives on the recent issue. It was challenging to identify initially, but an employee spotted a flawed procedure, prompting everyone to address it quickly. Within a week, we resolved the issue with the FAA, identified the affected airplanes, and began the necessary rework. This is an indication of a robust supply chain rather than a weak one. We will continue to foster a positive relationship with Spirit. Brian noted our readiness to provide them with cash support as they navigate their recovery process. We will remain constructive, and I have confidence in Tom and the Spirit team to overcome this challenge. We have been engaged with them regarding rate increases and supply chain needs for quite some time, and we believe they will achieve their goals.
Speaker
Following up on the supplier master schedule for the 737 MAX, how long will the supply chain operate at a higher production rate than your final production rate? Additionally, what will the cost be for that inventory build? Brian West (CFO): Yes. It's a matter of months, Kristine. Thanks for the question. It's a matter of months, and the inventory is all contemplated in our forward look. It's not anything we worry too much about. In fact, again, another indication of how we're thinking about this, we're perfectly comfortable keeping everyone at pace and hold a little buffer. We think that's a better alternative than keeping it a little bit too close to the wire. And we're going to keep having that posture, and that's going to help us get to 38 and then beyond.
Speaker
Great. And a follow-up on Seth's question on the labor agreement with Spirit. Should we see a production disruption at Spirit? What are mitigating actions you could take? And are there things that you could do to make it easier for you to meet your targets if, again, there is a production disruption at Spirit? David Calhoun (CEO): Yes, I'm not going to speculate on that. I'm going to assume that our supplier and the workforce at our supplier are good enough and smart enough and can play far enough ahead to not worry about that. Matt Welch (Head of Investor Relations): And Lois, we have time for one final question.
Speaker
Can you touch on BGS margins in the quarter? I think this is like the highest you put it since you broke that out. I know you mentioned the mix was positive, but can you say how much of that benefit was? I think this is kind of like a mid-teens margin pre-COVID. Should we expect to kind of gravitate back to that level? Or could it be kind of a little bit higher here? Brian West (CFO): Yes. Thanks for the question. We love the service business, right? It's a franchise that goes on for years and years and years. And the good news is, as Dave mentioned, on the commercial side, we're back to pre-pandemic levels. That's a healthy sign. And the team is very focused on profitable, capital-efficient growth. And that's important in the service business. So I think we're set up very well. The quarter, a little bit of a mix benefit. But overall, we're set up very well to deliver a mid-single-digit revenue growth business with mid-teens margins and high cash flow conversion just like we set out in November. And we get more and more confident about that business and the team that's running it. So I think it's going to accrue to our benefit over the next several years. David Calhoun (CEO): And if I just think in my short 3 years or maybe it feels long, we made a lot of changes to services, and we tightened up the capital disciplines in a pretty significant way. They all leaned in favor of higher margin, more intellectual property content in our work that we do. And of course, we now have a supply-constrained market around that. So I'm not surprised these margins have expanded, and I'm not expecting them to go down. I think the team is doing a great job. Matt Welch (Head of Investor Relations): And that concludes our first quarter earnings call. Thank you, everybody.
Operator
Thank you. And ladies and gentlemen, that does conclude the Boeing First Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. Thank you for joining.
Need more earnings data?
Explore more earnings information and financial data for BA
Transcript sourced from Financial Modeling Prep (FMP)