Navigation

Investiment.io
Financial analysis platform

The Boeing Company

BA • NYSE

$165.22
ā–¼6.28 (3.66%)• REGULAR

The Boeing Company

$165.22
ā–¼3.7%
šŸ“ŠSummaryšŸ“‹SEC FilingsšŸ‘„Insider Trading
šŸ“„

BA Q3 2023 Earnings Call

October 25, 2023 at 12:00 AM

Company
BA
Quarter
Q3 2023
Date
October 25, 2023 at 12:00 AM
Speakers
2
Word Count
~8,807

Transcript Content

Operator
Thank you. And our first question will come from Doug Harned from Bernstein. Please go ahead.
Speaker
Yes, good morning. Thank you. Talking about the recovery here, when we look at the 737 MAX ramp, we had thought you'd be at 38 a month production back in August, and we were looking forward to a new line that should be up and running at Everett in 2025, which looks to us that we give you capacity for well over 60 a month. But now that 38 a month rate is coming – is still to come later this year. And if I separate the bottlenecks here into three topics, sort of engines, Spirit, and everything else, engines appear fine. You’ve got a new leadership at Spirit, a new agreement. So this is not just one part, but I guess how much has your longer-term ramp outlook changed, given the Spirit issues you’ve had this year? And if you could take those Spirit risks off the table, what bottlenecks are still out there in the everything else category for the MAX? And to put it all together, what could this ramp look like if you can avoid quality escapes like the ones we have seen this year? Dave Calhoun (CEO): Yes, Doug, that’s the money question. We think we are synced perfectly with the constraints that we know. You talked about engine constraints. We have as clear and as transparent a relationship as we could possibly have with the GE and CFM teams. The rates that we have outlined in our guidance reflect those constraints. We all could go much higher, much faster, if it were strictly a demand question. But we have to listen hard to those constraints. So we are there. On Spirit, we really do believe that the commercial agreement and I can have Brian make a comment on; he was in the center of that negotiation. The commercial agreement gives them the resources and the breathing room they need to get ahead of our rate forecast. And maybe even more importantly, I think the selection of Pat at exactly this moment in time to sort of get them really focused on factory performance, I’m quite optimistic and quite pleased with. We’ve had just in the last 30 days as many interactions with Pat as we’ve had over the last year, even though we’ve had more than 100 people embedded at Spirit. So, all the signs are good there. I feel like we took a major step forward on relieving that particular constraint. And as you know, that is mostly a conformance constraint. I got to tell you, these fuselages, man, they have been gone over with a microscope in light of what we’ve experienced here in the last four months. So all that said, those are – you correctly articulated the constraints that we’ve had to deal with. On the all other, we had one that has really taken aggressive steps and gotten ahead of us. And so I’m feeling better about all other than I have in quite a long time just because there was another one embedded. I’m not going to mention names. So anyway, that’s it in a nutshell, I am always tempted based on demand to tell you we can do more than 50 and get to 60 and we are physically capacitized to do it. You’re correct in that. But I can’t call it out until the supply chain constraints can make it. And they haven’t yet to get to those kinds of numbers. But we have a couple of years to work it, and we’ll continue to work it. But right now, everything we’re doing is based on the constraints we know. And that’s what we’ve outlined to the industry. And even in these last just several months with the non-conformance issues that have sort of constrained our delivery, as we’ve said many times, we have kept our master schedule intact to get to that 38. We’re definitely building inventory in the process, and we’re paying our suppliers. So they’re not second guessing where we’re going to end up. And we think we’re going to have a little bit of buffer, particularly at the front end in light of what we’ve just experienced.
Speaker
And is there any point that we should be looking toward where you might have more clarity on how that whole supply chain is going to come together for this? Dave Calhoun (CEO): Yes, first of all, we’ll definitely update guidance for next year as we get into the early part of next year, put these non-conformances in a rear view mirror once and for all, get to a stable rate at 38, and then we’re going to be anxious to build from there as fast as we can. We will give guidance based on everything we know early in that year. So not avoiding it now, but its best we get these things in a rear view mirror. And the good news is we really do have these in a box with respect to the scope of work that’s required and now it’s just executing against it. And our teams have done a pretty good job on that.
Speaker
Okay. Thank you.
Operator
Thank you. The next question is from the line of Jason Gursky with Citi. Please go ahead.
Speaker
Good morning, everybody. Brian, you made some comments in September about expectations for cash flow in 2024 and the past two year goals in 2025 and described things back in September potentially being nonlinear. So you’ve had some things that have happened since then, including the pushout of some deliveries into 2024. You’ve incurred some more charges, I think that were a bit greater than you were expecting in the Defense business. I’m wondering if you can kind of update us on the current thought on 2024 cash flow and kind of the puts and takes that you’re expecting. What are the good guys, what are the bad guys relative to 2023? And then maybe just provide us some thoughts on the quantum of cash that you expect to generate at the company, 2023, 2024, 2025, and 2026, given all that’s occurred here, particularly in the defense business here since you lead out those goals at your Investor Day last year, whether the quantum of cash that you expect to generate over those four years has changed materially? Thanks. Brian West (CFO): Yes. Thanks, Jason. Let me start with the quantum and the 2025, 2026 time frame. It’s $10 billion. And we continue to have line of sight to hitting that target. I think that’s most important. In terms of how we get from where we land in 2023 to that moment, yes, going to be some things we’ve got to deal with, not going to be linear, but we’ve got some things that feel good about in terms of momentum. Let me just highlight a few. Of course, we’ll be more specific in January on next year’s free cash flow guidance. But we expect to be higher. It’s too early to be that specific, but it will be underwritten by higher BCA deliveries, both on the 737 and the 787. We’ll have made progress on the inventory wind down that Dave mentioned. And we’re also going to factor in the 777X ramp. So those things are pretty discrete, and we just got to follow our ability to deliver in a stable environment. BGS will be steady. BDS, as you point out, we expect cash flows next year to be better than there this year, but still likely a drag, mostly factoring in the impact of some of the charges that you mentioned that we just got to put behind us. So, we’ll spell all of this out in January once we finish our planning cycle and get through 2023. But the most important thing to remember is that quantum in 2025, 2026 is $10 billion. And all of the levers that we have to go from where we land this year to at that point are still very clear to us and underwritten by execution, and we know how to do that.
Speaker
Okay. And then, Brian, just if you don’t mind, the $10 billion quantum out in 2025, 2026, can you talk about the potential for – where we might go from there? What are some of the puts and takes that we might see from a growth perspective beyond that $10 billion? Brian West (CFO): Yes. We’re still looking forward to that stability, as Dave called it, in the 2025, 2026 time frame in that $10 billion. That’s where we’re laser-like focused. Anything beyond that is going to be outside of our planning window. And hopefully, it’s going to be underwritten by a very attractive robust demand environment, but let’s get there first.
Operator
Thank you. The next question is from Peter Arment from RW Baird. Please go ahead.
Speaker
Yes, thanks. Good morning, Dave and Brian. Dave Calhoun (CEO): Hi, Peter.
Speaker
Hey Brian, maybe just to talk about stability there because you just brought it up on – if we look at just the remaining two months of the year, if you’re going to deliver about 15 737s in the – in October, that kind of implies that you need to deliver high 30s or high 40s if you’re going to be at the upper end of your range. Just kind of the confidence level around that for November, December, I mean. And if you could update us on when you talked about the – in September, I think about the 75% of the MAX aircraft in storage had to be inspected. What’s the latest there? And just lastly, is there – is the – getting to 38 a month later in the year, does that impact any of your rate break decisions when you’re thinking about 2024? Thanks again. Brian West (CFO): Yes, sure. So October will be a little bit light, as I mentioned, with November and December being picked up. Remember, we had a number of airplanes that were ready to be delivered prior to this latest Spirit NOE, and now we have to work them through the system. We do have a good line of sight to finish in the year, and the team is laser-like focused on meeting this updated set of numbers. And then, of course, we feel good about the free cash flow that will be dragged along with that. In terms of the 75%, that is still the way to think about how we have to touch those inventory airplanes. As we’ve mentioned, we know the scope. We know what’s got to happen, and we’re working our way through finishing that work across that cohort of airplanes. So that has remained unchanged, and it’s just all the work we have to do in front of us, clear line of sight. And in terms of the rate breaks, largely speaking, we’ve had a master schedule out there for some time with the required rate breaks. Of course, we’re trying to get our way to 50 per month by the 2025, 2026 time frame. None of that’s changed. And we’re still focused on executing that once we can get to that 38 as we exit this year and then move the supply chain with us considering everything Dave described about how we see the supply chain coordinating going forward.
Speaker
Appreciate the color. Thanks guys.
Operator
The next question is from the line of Myles Walton from Wolfe Research. Please go ahead.
Speaker
Hi guys, good morning. Brian or Dave, looking at the $10 billion target for 2025, 2026, is there a way that we can have confidence yet that even if BDS is nearly neutral that the rest of the organization can still get to that number? And then also, if you can just highlight the space satellite constellation charge. I’m always a little bit curious when I first hear about it if I’m going to hear about it again, so maybe just lay out the trajectory of that program. Thanks. Brian West (CFO): Sure. So I’ll take the last one first. This is a particular contract with the customer that really isn’t in the category of development. The way we talk about the fixed-price development contracts is very different. We are completing the requirements for the customer. We have additional work to do to make this constellation very robust with new technology. It’s very innovative, and we have to work our way through, and we will in short order. This is not going to be one that’s going to be dragged out for a long period of time. And in terms of the 10 billion, we always built that with some understanding that not every piece was going to go exactly correct. There were going to be some puts and takes and we provide ourselves the room with which we could have certain things not go quite perfectly. And in the case of BDS, even though it might be a bit different than we had thought even a year ago, it’s still within the quantum of us being able to deliver that 10 billion. And we have a lot of confidence that they will be contributing to that 10 billion. Maybe not quite as much, but they’re going to be positive. And of course, BGS remains strong. BCA, we always get more and more confident. So we still have a path to that 10 billion and just reinforce how confident we are in get – being able to get the whole enterprise there.
Speaker
Okay. Thank you.
Operator
Thank you. And the next question is from Sheila Kahyaoglu from Jefferies. Please go ahead.
Speaker
Good morning, Dave, Brian, and Matt. Thanks so much. And I just wanted to dig into commercial airplanes and just the operating loss there of $678 million. Brian, I know you’ve been out there in the trenches working with suppliers. You called out another loss in Q4. So maybe as you think about the production rates normalizing, can you maybe parse out how much of the losses are linked to concessions, pricing, supply chain constraints, and how you expect that to turn? Brian West (CFO): Yes. Thanks, Sheila. So it’s largely – the fact that we were negative again in the quarter is all the Spirit impact that we’ve described. And fourth quarter is going to be sequentially better, but it’s still going to be negative. And that’s again, as we work our way through this factory disruption and we still have this abnormal running through the BCA P&L. I will tell you that in 2024, we expect margins to be positive and that’s going to be underwritten by two things primarily BCA. It’s going to be driven by higher volume for sure. And remember all this abnormal will be essentially done which has been a drag on the BCA margins for quite some time. So we just got to work our way out of that, which we will by the end of this year, and then work towards executing on the delivery targets for next year. And that will get back at a positive territory. And then the good news is by 2025, 2026, we still have a view where they will be double-digit margins as they have been historically. And that will be underwritten by this. These dual factories that Dave’s talked about will be behind us. And all of that labor that today is working on inventory airplanes for both the 737 and the 787 is going to go be applied to these ramps in the rates up to 50 and 10 respectively in the 737 and the 787. So all of that still is right in front of us and it all still gives us confidence that we’re going to be able to hit those kind of targets. And the BCA team is very focused on delivering that.
Speaker
Okay, great. Thank you.
Operator
Thank you. Our next question is from Cai von Rumohr from TD Cowen. Please go ahead.
Speaker
Yes, thanks a lot. So Brian, 777X R&D spiked up. It looks like total R&D at BCA was up about $150 million sequentially. Where do those – where does the 777X sort of R&D number go moving forward? When does it peak? When does it come down? And also maybe you could update us on the certification status given we’re in a CR, are we going to make it on MAX 7 by year-end? What about MAX 10? What about achieving TIA on the 777X? Brian West (CFO): Yes. So let’s start with the R&D question. So overall R&D, we continue to spend on the dash seven and the dash 10 and the uptick is as I pointed out and as you mentioned on the 777X and the 777-8 Freighter. Now as we move forward, that range of three – call it three, four-ish billion of R&D, that’s going to modestly go up over the next couple years. But it’s not going to do anything to disrupt our free cash flow target. And if it goes up a little bit, I think that’ll be good news because we’re investing in programs. So we’re not necessarily worried about that at all. And it’s all within our expectations, both near term and longer term. And in terms of the certification milestones that we have in front of us, as Dave mentioned, there’s been no change to either the dash seven, the dash 10 or the 777X we move forward and particularly the 777X team’s hard at work at trying to meet that commitment. So there’s really nothing to say other than there’s a lot of people hard at work, which is why we continue to invest in those spots. Dave Calhoun (CEO): I always have to add because I don’t want to get in a trap like we did a long time ago. The FAA makes that call and we’re going to give them all the flexibility they need. We try to interpret it the best we can, and that’s what we’ve done. Know that there haven’t been any real changes to the airplanes. So we are mostly working design assurance documentation as required by the new legislation back at the end of 2020.
Speaker
And on the issue of 777X, TIA, when do you expect that? Brian West (CFO): I don’t think that we’ve necessarily put a date out on that for obvious reasons. So we’ll let the teams do the work and we’ll let the regulators dictate those specifics, and we’re just going to follow their lead.
Speaker
Thank you very much.
Operator
Thank you. And the next question is from Seth Seifman from JPMorgan. Please go ahead.
Speaker
Hey. Thanks very much. Good morning everyone. Brian, with your comment that the 2023 cash flow is going to come in at the low end of the range, your expectation for growth in 2024. I guess, should we be expecting 2024 to be in the 2023 range when we're trying to get a draw beat on where 2024 is? And then within that, the 737s, sometimes I think it's hard to bridge between production and deliveries. If it's 38 a month exiting the year, can we say at least 38 times 12 next year plus some chunk of the inventory that's remaining? Brian West (CFO): Yes. So Seth, we're just going to wait until January to be able to describe any kind of range for cash flow next year. We just got to get through our planning cycle. We had to close the year. So just be patient with us. But we will be specific in January, the same way we were this year. And I'll also probably let you know that, that would apply to your question on deliveries or how to think about them. Delivery is going to be higher next year. We're going to have momentum going on this year. All of those details, we're going to flesh out and share at the beginning of the year and at the right time, and we look forward to doing that.
Speaker
Okay. Thanks very much.
Operator
The next question is from Noah Poponak from Goldman Sachs. Please go ahead.
Speaker
Hey. Good morning everyone. Dave Calhoun (CEO): Hi, Noah. Brian West (CFO): Hi, Noah.
Speaker
Brian, just staying on the 737 pace for me, recognizing you're not going to give a number for next year, it sounds like. But if October is similar to September, it implies November, December are decent delivery numbers. So is it the case that the aft fuselage issue and the incremental inspection of hand-drilled in addition to laser-drilled fasteners, that, that is kind of behind you as you get to January 1st? It's not impacting 2024, 737 deliveries. And then when you're talking about being at 38 a month out in the off-the-line final assembly versus where the system is, is a different number, is there a wide gap in that to start the year? Or can we think out a real clean stable 38 a month to start the year? Brian West (CFO): Answer your first question, the answer is yes, for sure. And in terms of how we think about the rate, we, the system, as Dave mentioned has always maintained to be hot because we want to make sure that they know that the demand signal is there. And we want them to continue to focus on that master schedule. How exactly we start the year we'll be able to count deliveries relative to that 38, we'll see. But right now, job one is to exit – get the non-conformance behind us. Remember, we had about a 30 aircraft growth between the second quarter and the third quarter into the inventory airplane. So that's going to be working its way out of the system relatively quickly, which gives us confidence in the November, December time frame. And then as we think about prime of the pump for 38 per month, we're going to move towards January and beyond and hopefully some pretty good execution. So we'll have to wait and see exactly how that plays out, but the underlying system is going to stay at 38. And as we get through next year, obviously, there'll be certain rate ramps that we'll describe later. But right now, if we have everything be coordinated across the broad supply chain, I think we'll be fine.
Speaker
Okay. And I guess putting a lot of this together and everybody trying to figure out where the 2024 free cash is going to land. Is it kind of reasonable to think of 2024 as just two halves and that some of your hesitation in giving some of those numbers is you just don't know exactly where the year starts. Is there still some 737 disruption? 787 at five is a different margin than 787 at 10? Maybe BDS margins are still negative in the first half, but they're positive in the second half. And so this next year's first half free cash flow just still have some of 2023 elements lingering in it, but that the second half will be kind of run-rating into more of what your stable looks like and maybe second half 2024 looks, the numbers look more like second half of 2022 type of free cash flow numbers. And we can comfortably think of that as run-rating into your future? Brian West (CFO): Yes. No, all of that is going to have to be something we talk about in January. Right now, we have to get the non-conformance behind us. We have to be able to hit this delivery range that we've just described. And we have a lot to do, but confidence we'll get there. And then we'll describe the shape of next year at the right time. I just don't want to get too far ahead of ourselves. And I do believe that next year will be better, and I do believe we'll exit next year better. How that folds up between halves, you're just going to have to give us a little bit more time as we work our way through our planning cycle and we get to January. Dave Calhoun (CEO): Noah, if I could just maybe add one thing to make sure everybody knows what, at least what I'm all focused on. We're going to exit this year with a little more than 100 of the return-to-service airplanes that we had at the end of 2020. That is what our shadow factories are focused on in a big way to make sure that we can bleed that down to basically nothing by the end of next year. So the pace at which we bleed that down, we complete that rework, deliver all those airplanes dictates a lot about that cash flow. It gets better every month. But it's going to be all about the pace at which we can do it and transfer that workforce into the production rate increases. So we need – there's a lot to know about that. We're going to give you our best shot at what that guidance looks like. But by way of proxy, that is a very important achievement for us. And I'm 100% focused on it, and I know Brian is and the team at BCA.
Speaker
Okay, thanks so much. Dave Calhoun (CEO): Yep.
Operator
Thank you. Our next question is from David Strauss from Barclays. Please go ahead.
Speaker
Thanks. Good morning everyone. Dave Calhoun (CEO): Good morning.
Speaker
Wanted to ask about the supply chain. Are there any other spots – hot spots in the supply chain where you've either had to infuse a meaningful amount of cash like you did with Spirit or are in negotiations to do something similar to what you've done with Spirit? That's the first question. And then the second question, I guess a clarifying comment for Brian. On the BCA margin progression next year turning positive, is that both on a program on a unit basis or would that just be on a program basis? Thanks. Dave Calhoun (CEO): Brian, how about I answer the first part of this one? I consider the Spirit remedy fairly unique, in fact, totally unique. I don't think that's going to have any ramifications anywhere else, and there aren't any signals that way. But the linkage really is important. As Spirit becomes stable and we get to our rates, rates solve most of the supply chain's problems. We got to get to those rates so that they can make the kind of money that they associate with those rates and we get to where we need. So there is a linkage, but it's not a copycat linkage, and there's no sign of that happening. Brian West (CFO): And in terms of the margins on both unit and program, they'll be positive. And program, we'll have growth. So we look forward to describing that as we get closer to January but both.
Operator
Thank you. And our next question is from Rich Safran from Seaport Research Partners. Please go ahead.
Speaker
Thanks, Brian, Matt. Good morning. I got a two-part tanker-related question for you. First, with Lockheed dropping out, when do you expect an award? And what could that do to your overall assessment of program profitability? I'm basically assuming here that you would have to review the accounting on the program. Second part is with deliveries restarting, what's being anticipated? I mean, how much of a catch-up should we expect in 4Q? And is that being factored into your guide? Dave Calhoun (CEO): Well, let me just comment on the tanker. I'm not surprised at what we all read with respect to Airbus now going on their own. They will go. So we shouldn't expect them to sort of vacate. I do like what it ultimately does for us and the competition. We are not afraid of competition. And yes, that next contract matters a lot. We have to ultimately underwrite the cost and get this right. And as we've committed to you all along, we're going to stay disciplined on that front. And no, there's not – this isn't program accounting, it's contract accounting. So I don't think we're going to have any implication associated with lots and an additional contract. Now I'm not the accountant. So I'll ask Brian to collaborate. Brian West (CFO): Yes. No, exactly. We don't see that changing. We'll just add to volume like we do with any kind of extension. And in terms of your question in the fourth quarter, of course, any kind of deliveries and cash flow are going to be factored into our look for the quarter and going forward. So that's all baked in.
Operator
Thank you and that concludes our call this morning. I appreciate everybody joining. Thank you again. Dave Calhoun (CEO): Thank you. Brian West (CFO): Thanks.
Operator
Thank you and that completes The Boeing Company's Third Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. Thank you all for joining and you may now disconnect.