📄
T Q4 2022 Earnings Call
January 25, 2023 at 12:00 AM
🔍
Company
T
Quarter
Q4 2022
Date
January 25, 2023 at 12:00 AM
Speakers
2
Word Count
~8,701
Transcript Content
Operator
Our first question today comes from Brett Feldman with Goldman Sachs.
Speaker
I think I'll start off with a follow-up here on the outlook that you provided. I appreciate some of the color that Pascal provided about the different operating segments. Maybe at a higher level, could you give us a sense as to what you mean by a more difficult operating environment? In other words, to what extent does the outlook for this year anticipate maybe a recession or ongoing inflationary pressures? And then I imagine one of the questions we’ll be getting today are, what are some of the key swing factors? And so if we were to use your adjusted EBITDA guidance as an example, what's the scenario that gets you to 3% growth, and what could be the swing factors that might take that into the higher category? John Stankey (CEO): Hi, Brett. Let me go ahead, and I'll start and then Pascal can jump in. First of all, look at the foundation of what we're telling you is we've been I think, very conservative and thoughtful in the guidance we pulled together. It is a tough environment to predict. There's a lot of geopolitical things going on that I think anybody would have a hard time seeing and doing a crystal ball on, and that's probably the most difficult wildcard that I think we've tried to take a conservative stance of what we see in the economy today and what the foundation that's rested on is. We know that the services that we provide to customers are pretty resilient even during more challenged economic times. So we have a reasonably high confidence level that our customers are going to continue to want to use the product and pay us for it. I think if you go back and look at my public comments probably over a year ago, I've had a relatively conservative view of where I thought the economy was going to go. I've been fairly vocal that I think inflation is a tough thing to have a healthy economic environment and that's good for everybody and it creates some challenges in places. Ultimately, a lot of that came to pass. The good news is I think we're through the worst of it, and we see it easing. But as you heard from my comments, we've expected that we're going to continue dealing with some of that pressure as we move through this year. We don't have an outlook that says that we've solved the problem. We have an outlook that says we're going to continue to deal with pressures that are hitting some of our line items economically that we've got to account for and things like energy and some of the continued wage and employment pressures that we've had to deal with that will carry through and we have some longer-term contracts that didn't come up during the last year that we know are going to hit us this year in renewals that we have to factor into that. We've tried to do the best we can around it. I see the economy being relatively stable right now. We're not seeing anything that's causing us to be extremely concerned about it. But what happens later in the year, who knows? The point we've made is we've kind of assumed that we're not going to be in a robust growth environment as we make our way through the year. I would tell you if you're asking kind of what the swing factors are, I think the swing factor, frankly, is if there's some kind of a geopolitical disruption that's something significant that none of us anticipated or that we hope would never happen; it creates a disruptive event. That's probably the thing I'd look at and say, I couldn't predict it. I couldn't plan for it, and that's going to be the issue that we have to deal with that just pops up and isn't going to be just an AT&T issue. Pascal Desroches (CFO): Yes. Brett, the only other thing I would add is, look, we've assumed in our outlook a more normalized industry growth environment. So to the extent it's more than that or less than that, that could be a swing factor. But the thing that I think is important, and I said this in my comments there is, whatever the environment is, we expect to perform relatively well versus the peer set.
Operator
And our next question comes from the line of John Hodulik with UBS.
Speaker
I have a couple of quick follow-ups regarding capital uses. Pascal, you may have mentioned this earlier, but what is behind the $2 billion in working capital savings this year, and how confident are you in that? Also, can you give us an overview of the CapEx side, which is again set at $24 billion this year? What is the long-term outlook for that, and when can we expect it to start decreasing? What do you consider to be a more normalized level of CapEx, especially with the current investments in Gigapower and various fiber initiatives? Pascal Desroches (CFO): Sure thing, John. Here is the way I think about the $2 billion that I flagged in our guidance for 2023. The last several years, we've been growing our subscribers in wireless with that came some upfront acquisition costs. We've said for a while we expect that to level out in 2023. Once you have that leveling out, we are no longer going to be spending more each and every year than the prior year in acquisitions. So that leveling out, there is assets that are on the books associated with the deferred acquisition costs of those subscribers. That's going to be amortized; we have great visibility into that amortization, and that's obviously noncash because we spent the cash in the prior year. So that we have very good visibility to. If we grow more than last year in terms of wireless subscribers, that could be a swing factor, but I don't anticipate that.
Speaker
Got it. And then the CapEx? Pascal Desroches (CFO): CapEx, the thing to keep in mind is we plan to be at peak levels in '22 and '23 because of the significant contributions that we are getting from DIRECTV in '22 and '23's CapEx is fairly meaningful amounts for spectrum deployment and transformation that will begin to moderate as we exit this year. We haven't updated the guide we provided at Investor Day, but clearly, we expect to trend down towards more normalized capital intensity as we exit this year.
Operator
And our next question comes from the line of Phil Cusick with JPMorgan.
Speaker
Turning to fiber, Gigapower was a great announcement, but it was slightly smaller than we anticipated. John, how do you view the 1.5 million compared to the potential of that venture or similar models? Regarding your on-balance sheet fiber construction, which you mentioned is around $2 million to $2.5 million annually, it appears to be progressing at a slower pace than we previously discussed. Is there any change there? Lastly, to clarify on Pascal’s point about free cash flow, will working capital contribute $2 billion to free cash flow in '23, or is it just offsetting what was a $2 billion drag in '22? John Stankey (CEO): First of all, I consider our fiber portfolio as a set of options to evaluate where the returns are most favorable for our capital deployment. I want to make it clear that we recognize the importance of being disciplined in our decisions regarding this portfolio and ensuring that our capital investments lead to acceptable returns. I understand that the Gigapower announcement is a new model that may be unfamiliar to our investors. I want to approach this with care, similar to how we managed our in-region fiber investments, and I've been open about our progress regarding the economic returns of that investment. We've shared details like average revenue per user and penetration rates to help you see that this is a sustainable long-term investment. The Gigapower model differs from what you might typically expect in terms of returns. To reassure you about our incremental investments in this venture, 1.5 million homes represents over $1 billion of investment. We've structured this initial phase to provide you with information over the next 18 months to build your confidence in the anticipated returns. The management team and partnership are geared towards achieving this goal. We plan to market this very soon after our announcement and I aim to provide 12 months of penetration data to support our success. If we succeed, it's possible that the scope could exceed 1.5 million homes. I also want to be mindful about determining what we should manage independently and what might be better suited for a partnership, similar to our wireless infrastructure approach from years ago. If we achieve outstanding results, we may decide to handle some of this ourselves instead of through a partnership. Conversely, if we need greater scale and speed, we now have a setup that allows us to swiftly increase funding and capacity. We’ll have data to share with you to ensure you're aligned with our progress. I see this as a flexible tool that provides us with numerous options. Regarding the in-region fiber aspect, I'm aiming for a diverse portfolio of returns. I've described the high-return options we see within our 30 million passings commitment. I've tried to clarify this because I know some of you are calculating the numbers. We now have additional options, and I want to assess the return characteristics of the Gigapower initiative compared to our organic in-region efforts. Some of the funding we'll pursue, particularly through BEAD, may yield very different returns than our current organic initiatives. I want to keep our options open to explore this aspect of the portfolio. I expect to have more clarity by the end of the third quarter on our success in securing that funding, the capacity additions we’ll need to achieve our business goals, and how this aligns with our operational territories and overall strategy moving forward. That's my overall perspective, and I’ll let Pascal address your question on the free cash flow clarification. Pascal Desroches (CFO): Hey, Phil, the straightforward way I view the majority of the $2 billion is that we have deferred acquisition costs recorded from previous years. This amortization will continue to be accounted for against EBITDA in 2023. These are noncash expenses impacting our results. So when we add that back to our EBITDA, it will increase the cash EBITDA generated by the business. John Stankey (CEO): If I can follow up on one. Start to be a split. Do you look at Gigapower and BEAD spending as alternative places to spend your capital and effectively now slowing the organic pace to get to that 30 million? I've outlined the timeline for reaching the 30 million, and I don't expect that to change. We are committed to what I just shared with you. Therefore, I will not be providing any incremental revisions to the 30 million figure. Pascal Desroches (CFO): To clarify, Phil, the BEAD funding and Gigapower are additional to the 30 million. John Stankey (CEO): Yes, if that's your question, 100%.
Operator
Our next question comes from the line of Simon Flannery with Morgan Stanley.
Speaker
Great. If I could just stay on the broadband theme, if I could. Perhaps I think you talked perhaps about providing extra color on the financial construct of the BlackRock JV? Are you contributing any capital? Any assets how exactly should we expect that to flow through the financials? And John, on the BEAD, perhaps you just give us a reflection on the status of the process, the timing, how this is going to play out. I think there's been a lot of concerns about delays, the mapping process, the challenges and also some of the state broadband offices maybe not being ready to stand this up. So how do you see this evolving? And when do you think you can actually get shovels in the ground to get know what funding been awarded? And then just finally, getting to 30 million locations is great. What about the prebuilding with fiber with fixed wireless in some of those locations? I think you've talked about that. And how does fixed wireless play into some of that other 30 million plus locations that won't be getting fiber in the near term? John Stankey (CEO): Sure. Simon, I need to be careful about discussing the partnership. It's a separate structure, so you shouldn't expect to see any financials on our balance sheet; instead, it will be recorded as investment income. We'll provide updates on its success as it progresses, and both partners will share equal responsibility in executing the venture. That should give you a clear understanding of how it unfolds. If you have more questions, I can provide additional details. Regarding the BEAD timing, I believe there is enough information available now. We're in a clarification phase for the initial data, which is moving along reasonably well. The larger states with more staffing capabilities are responding quickly and effectively. While some smaller states may take longer to organize, I believe the major states, which will receive the majority of funding, are focused and progressing rapidly. This shouldn’t slow down the more proactive states or our ability to start seeing funds flowing from the Federal government back to the states for implementation in the third quarter. However, I don't anticipate seeing significant projects starting this year. We will likely see funding awarded before the year ends, with projects commencing in 2024, primarily in larger states with adequate resources to expedite the process. I expect we'll be able to enhance our wireless distribution strengths in the business sector to offer a stronger fixed wireless broadband option to our customers and create bundles where it makes sense. Pascal Desroches (CFO): One other point on the capital structure for the JV to consider is that we do expect it to carry a meaningful amount of debt funding as well.
Speaker
Okay. Great. Are you contributing anything to it? Any capital, any assets? Yes. John Stankey (CEO): We have contributed some into the partnership. The reason you're going to see it get off the ground as quickly as it will and bring its first customers on in relatively short orders is because while we have been structuring and negotiating this, we've been doing a fair amount of work in parallel quietly. The partnership, as we've indicated, is already structured with the management team that's in place that has been doing a lot of work on the offer, knows the markets we're going to be in that have infrastructure and system setup that they can be ready to go on. This is probably one of the things our partner found attractive about this. It's a first-class management team with a lot of capabilities behind it, and we will take some credit for the contribution of that work that we've done within the scope of this year.
Operator
And our next question comes from the line of David Barden with Bank of America.
Speaker
I wanted to revisit the idea of the wireless postpaid phone market returning to a state of normalcy. Many people notice the strong correlation between the significant increase in the industry to around 9 million postpaid phone adds annually over the past few years and AT&T's revitalized growth, as John mentioned, over the last 10 quarters. As a result, when discussing the industry's normalization, there seems to be a tendency to assume that any future growth will primarily benefit AT&T, given its recent successes. Can you discuss this perspective and whether it realistically influences your working capital and cash flow, or if you believe that any downturn would affect the industry more evenly? Additionally, John, you mentioned something in your prepared remarks that hasn’t been heavily discussed in the U.S. regarding copper decommissioning, particularly in light of your fiber initiative. In Canada, for example, it's a major topic due to excess copper plant infrastructure. Can you provide more details on this? Is it too soon to consider it a positive factor for 2024, or is it already noticeable? John Stankey (CEO): Sure, Dave. How are you? I don't agree with your perspective at this time. I completely reject your viewpoint. I don't believe that's how the market is structured and functioning today. If I look back at our performance over the last two and a half years, I would say the industry is much healthier than some may suggest. Is competition increasing, or is it undermining itself? I see a consistently competitive industry throughout this period. I tend to evaluate not just based on customer counts but also on both wholesale and retail revenues and how that translates into service revenues. I observe a relatively balanced dynamic in the industry, and the numbers suggest we've been gaining some market share overall. I don't think that’s due to moving from an assumed normal of seven and a half million to nine million. In fact, among customers paying a reasonable monthly bill, we've captured more than our fair share, and I am more focused on gaining revenue and profitability share than merely subscriber share. Our figures indicate an improving trend over the last two and a half years in our ability to achieve that. I don’t subscribe to the idea that if the industry normalizes, we revert back to where we were three years ago. Our current position is due to our performance today, not what happened three years ago. Regarding legacy costs, I don’t expect a windfall from their restructuring. I've been emphasizing this for a while. We’ve been actively addressing this issue since I started, and we've been formulating plans that now put us in a well-functioning organization to execute this daily. I devote more time to discussing investments in new business opportunities and the growth potential from sustainable fiber and a 5G infrastructure than on what we are retiring from service, though we are indeed decommissioning equipment and removing it from the copper grid. Our reductions in energy costs and improvements in dispatch efficiency are due to managing a smaller operational footprint. We are continuously making progress in this area. The pace at which we are operating is increasing. I've shared insights about the number of products we've discontinued, which helps reduce operating costs. This contributes to what we project for ongoing improvements in our cost structure. You're beginning to see operating leverage come into play, partly because of how we manage legacy costs. When we provide cash forecasts for this year and discuss improvements to our cost structure, some of that is a result of our current efforts. I am keenly aware of our cost structure compared to others in the industry, some of whom don’t have the hybrid asset model we do, combining both fixed and mobile assets. We are committed to ensuring we're not at a disadvantage over the next several years. You will see this gradually come to fruition as we work through a somewhat painstaking process. It requires careful examination of each central office, line, and customer, but it's necessary. This can lead us to a better and healthier business, blending a strong fiber network with an excellent wireless network, which represents the future way customers will connect. I believe our hard work will be rewarded, but I acknowledge that we're developing new insights into navigating this space. I choose to grow this organically rather than through a front-end private equity deal that provides short-term cash but ultimately benefits someone else from our labor over the coming years.
Operator
And our next question comes from the line of Craig Moffett with SVB MoffettNathanson.
Speaker
I want to discuss your broadband portfolio. Considering your national footprint in Mobility, it seems that approximately 16% to 17% of the country already has excess fiber coverage, with an additional 10% to 12% expected to follow. Could you explain how you perceive the consumer value proposition in these different areas, specifically where you have wireless without fiber and where you have both? Additionally, what role do you see fixed wireless playing in enhancing that consumer value proposition? John Stankey (CEO): Yes, Craig. I view the current situation as a significant opportunity, even though I hesitate to call it a land rush because installing fiber is a more complex and time-consuming process. However, we're definitely in a period where a significant portion of the United States will eventually have fiber connectivity. Looking ahead, customers will increasingly prefer to purchase all their connectivity needs from a single provider, and the distinction between fixed and mobile services will blur. As we move forward, I anticipate a shift in the industry landscape toward this model. To be well positioned for this transformation, having the best technology and quickly establishing a large footprint will make a significant difference in how we engage in the changes to come, leading to a stronger relative customer base. It’s crucial to own and operate these assets while controlling product offerings and costs to ensure progress. Building fiber infrastructure, while integrating it with wireless services, is an intentional and robust process that I’m committed to executing efficiently. My responsibility is to ensure that our investors feel confident that we are generating successful returns with our incremental investments. I believe fixed wireless has a role in our overall strategy, but I do not see it as a viable long-term solution for densely populated urban or suburban areas. When considering consumer behavior and demand trends over the next few years, I don’t believe this approach will effectively meet customer needs in the short term. The mobile network is crucial for delivering capabilities outside of fixed locations, but its bandwidth limitations must be acknowledged. Mobile data is more valuable and should be priced accordingly due to the dynamics of supply and demand. It is essential for my mobile network to provide premium solutions for mobile data when needed. If we manage our mobile network effectively, we can capitalize on high-value mobile opportunities that will emerge with advancements in 5G technology and the demand for real-time transmission everywhere. Amir Rozwadowski (Head of Investor Relations): Thanks very much, Craig. Operator we have time for one last question.
Operator
And that last question comes from the line of Michael Rollins with Citi.
Speaker
Just thinking a little bit more about the wireless growth opportunity, can you share with us how AT&T is doing with the uptiering of customers onto unlimited and premium unlimited plans? Given some of the comments on inflation, are there opportunities for AT&T to update wireless and fiber pricing again this year? Are any of those opportunities included in the guidance? John Stankey (CEO): Hi, Mike. I'm not going to discuss our pricing plans today. However, I want to emphasize that we have a skilled management team that understands the value we provide to our customers and our position in the market. We are always assessing whether we are receiving the maximum value in exchange from our customers across all our products and services. Last year, we identified some customers who were not leveraging our best plans with the latest features, and we worked with them to help them recognize that there were options available that provided better value, even if it meant paying a bit more. We executed this initiative exceptionally well and saw strong churn numbers during that process, which speaks to our effective management. I'm not reporting a decline in service revenues or addressing a significant customer loss; rather, we have reduced churn, which reflects the success of creating a mutually beneficial arrangement with our customers. We will continue to seek such opportunities across our portfolio. There will always be ways for us to enhance our customer’s experience and value. With the ongoing 5G replacement cycle, we have opportunities to discuss product and service upgrades with customers, helping them choose plans that best fit their needs. We anticipate making further progress in this area, contributing to the service revenue growth we have previously guided. This isn't an overwhelming challenge; we've been discussing our strategy with you for years, and we've consistently met our service revenue forecasts. It's important to note that the global economy has not fully bounced back from the pandemic. As travel begins to normalize, we expect an uptick in revenue from international roaming as more global visitors return. While Asia may take longer to recover, recent policy changes provide hope for a return to pre-pandemic conditions. We are optimistic about this progression and confident in our ability to help customers find value in our offerings. We have room to grow, which is reflected in our guidance, and we will continue to execute our strategy effectively. Pascal, do you have anything to add? Pascal Desroches (CFO): No, I think that's all well said. John Stankey (CEO): I appreciate your time this morning. I'm really pleased with the year. I thought it was a strong, consistent execution year. I'm equally as pleased that we've done the right things to set us up for continued growth as we move through '23. I hope you feel the same. I know the management team is very focused on delivering what we shared with you this morning as our expectations. I feel really good about where our customer base is. As I mentioned just a few moments ago, to have churn levels in our wireless business running at the position they're in with the competitive intensity occurring in the industry to have the position we have with our broadband base on fiber and the customer satisfaction that's coming with it, I think bodes incredibly well even in an uncertain environment as we're moving forward. The good news is I think we can grow in both those places to continue to drive the kind of tempered indirect growth that we shared with you. We're looking forward to doing it again next year. I think we've got the right opportunities in place. There's a lot more that we know we can still do to run this business better, and we're about doing that to ensure that we deliver improved performance for you moving forward. Thank you very much. I hope you all have a great '23.
Operator
And ladies and gentlemen, that does conclude our conference for today. Thank you for your participation and for using AT&T Conferencing Service. You may now disconnect.
Need more earnings data?
Explore more earnings information and financial data for T
Transcript sourced from Financial Modeling Prep (FMP)