📄
TSM Q4 2023 Earnings Call
December 31, 2023 at 12:00 AM
🔍
Company
TSM
Quarter
Q4 2023
Date
December 31, 2023 at 12:00 AM
Speakers
1
Word Count
~6,833
Transcript Content
Speaker
Thank you, C.C. Good afternoon, everyone. First, let me talk about our global manufacturing footprint update. TSMC's mission is to be the trusted technology and capacity provider for the global logic IC industry for years to come. In today's fractured globalization environment, our strategy is to expand our global manufacturing footprint to increase our customer trust, expand our future growth potential, and reach for more global talent. Our overseas decisions are based on our customers' needs and a necessary level of government subsidy or support. This is to maximize the value for our shareholders. Firstly, in Japan, we are building a specialty technology fab in Kumamoto, which will utilize 12-nanometer, and 16-nanometer, and 22-nanometer, and 28-nanometer process technologies. We will hold an opening ceremony for this fab on February 2024, next month, and volume production is on track for the fourth quarter of 2024. In Arizona, we are in close and constant communication with the U.S. government on incentive and tax credit support and making strong progress in facility supply chain infrastructure, utility supply, and equipment installation for our first fab. We continue to work closely and develop strong relationships with our local union and trade partners in Arizona, including recently signed an agreement with the Arizona Building and Construction Trades Council for our new framework for cooperation. This agreement extends our collaboration across enhanced workforce training and development, shared commitment to site safety, hiring local workers, and establishing regular communication. It is a win-win for all parties. We are well on track for volume production of N4 or 4-nanometer process technology in the first half of 2025 and are confident that once we begin operations, we will be able to deliver the same level of manufacturing quality and reliability in Arizona as from our fabs in Taiwan. In Europe, we plan to build a specialty technology fab in Germany, focusing on automotive and industrial applications with our joint venture partners. We continue to be in close communication with the German federal, state, and city governments, and their commitment to this project remains strong and unchanged. Fab construction is scheduled to begin in Q4 2024 this year. In Taiwan, of course, we continue to invest in and expand our advanced technology capacities to support our customers' needs and their growth. Given the robust multiyear demand for our 3-nanometer technologies, we are expanding our 3-nanometer capacity in Taiwan Science Park. We are also preparing for our N2 volume production starting in 2025. We plan to build multiple fabs or multiple phases of 2-nanometer technologies in both Hsinchu and Kaohsiung Science Parks to support strong structural demand from our customers C.C. just mentioned. In Kaohsiung Science Park, the government approval process is ongoing and is also on track. While the initial cost of overseas fabs I previously mentioned are higher than TSMC's fabs in Taiwan, we are confident to manage and minimize the cost gap and remain committed to deliver profitable growth and maximize the value for our shareholders. Now let me talk about my retirement. On December 19th last year, I announced that I have decided not to seek nomination of Board members for the next term, and will retire from the company after the 2024 Annual Shareholders Meeting in June. Allow me to say this, over the past 30 years, I have been incredibly fortunate to work at and contribute to TSMC. I started at TSMC 30 years ago as a leader of a small four-person fab construction team. It has been my privilege to serve as Chairman of TSMC after our legendary Founder, Dr. Morris Chang, over the last six years. During this time, we have reaffirmed our commitment to our mission to be the trusted technology and capacity provider to the global logic IC industry for years to come while adhering to our core values of integrity, commitment, innovation, and customer trust. TSMC's success is predicated on providing the industry's most leading-edge processing technology at scale, in a cost-effective manner, to enable all the innovators to successfully offer their best products to the world. Together, we have worked diligently to enhance our focus on our technology leadership, competitiveness, global manufacturing footprint, digital excellence, sustainability, and corporate governance to maximize the value for our customers and our shareholders. The past 30 years with TSMC has been an extraordinary journey for me, and I want to extend my sincerest thanks to our incredible, talented team and all of TSMC's colleagues whose diligence, dedication, and can-do spirit have made the company into what it is today. Now, TSMC's nomination, corporate governance, and sustainability committee of the board has recommended Dr. C. C. Wei to succeed as the company's next Chairman, subject to the election of the incoming board in June 2024. If Dr. Wei is elected to be Chairman, he should also continue in his current role as CEO. Supported by a deep and experienced team of Senior Executives, many of whom have been with TSMC for many years, I remain fully confident in TSMC's strategy, leadership, and execution and firmly believe TSMC will continue to perform outstandingly in the years ahead. Thank you for your trust in TSMC, and the best is yet to come for the company and its shareholders. This concludes my messages and our key messages together. Jeff Su (Head of Investor Relations): Thank you, Chairman. This concludes our prepared statements. So, before we begin the Q&A session, I would like to remind everybody to please again limit your questions to two at a time, so we can allow all the participants an opportunity to ask their questions. Questions will be taken both from the floor and from the call online. Should you wish to raise your questions in Chinese, I will translate it to English before our management answers your question.
Speaker
It's great to see you again in person, Happy New Year. Allow me to remain seated. I have some long questions for you. So, the first question is to C.C. I am very curious about your comments about the technology leadership, because your competitor claims that their PPA is ahead of your 2-nanometer, even the cost is lower. So, I want to consult your opinion on why there's a different story and how do we judge. And given these debates, how is TSMC going to plan the future capacity for this customer and also competitor? We want to seize this opportunity but also avoid any overexpansion. C. C. Wei (CEO): Charlie, you named my customer's name, that’s my customer and my competitor. Let me repeat the last time when I commented on their technology. The comment stays the same, so their technology would be very similar or equivalent to TSMC's N3P. We further checked again with all the specs or the possible published in technology, transistor technology, and everything. My comment stays the same with a significant advantage in technology maturity. Because in 2025, when they say that their newest technology will go into production, for TSMC, that will be the third year with very high-volume production in the fabs. So again, I don't want to make too much of a comment on my customer's claim, but let me assure you we continue to have technology leadership, and we continue to have a broader base of customers who are almost all working with TSMC.
Speaker
In that case, would you aggressively spend on capacity because outsourcing is more likely? C. C. Wei (CEO): Certainly. We are expanding our capacity with US$28 billion to US$32 billion. That's a significant amount which we will use for our 3-nanometer and 2-nanometers capacity.
Speaker
Let me add some color to this. I think C.C. has been very modest. I think he has claimed that N3P is comparable to their 18A. We still affirm our statement. But I would like you to look at a different perspective. What C.C. and the other side claim might be right, but it's only for their own product, and IDN typically optimizes their technology for their product. We, as a foundry, optimize our technology for our customers' products. So, that's a significant difference. What you use for the high-power server could be very different than what is used for the smartphone or even the large data edge AI processors. So, you should look at this through a broader perspective.
Speaker
Thanks, Mark. So, Jeff, can I go to the second one? Yes. So, Mark, first of all, I really appreciate your leadership. I believe our global investors appreciate your past six-year contribution, creating a lot of shareholder value. Thank you. My question is about the content of your speech in November. The speech was about TSMC in the era of AI. You mentioned some very interesting data points. You used AI technology to improve the defect classification, and also the EUV throughput by, for example, 10%. Now with generative AI, can it be a significant breakthrough in terms of technology? Do you think Samsung or Intel, by leveraging generative AI, can really break through and catch up to your technology? And also, before your retirement, any kind of big unfinished goals or targets for TSMC?
Speaker
Thank you, Charlie. The talk I gave in last November was to audience members from Taiwan's industry companies. The purpose I want to convey was that I see artificial intelligence as a great opportunity for the industry in Taiwan. Just like Taiwan is a big country for semiconductors, it can also become a prominent player for artificial intelligence in the future; that was how I aimed to encourage them. As far as whether our competitors are using AI, of course, they use AI. Just look at all the AI companies in Silicon Valley or the U.S., that's not a secret. But on the other hand, AI is only in its nascent stage. Only last November, the first large language model, ChatGPT, was announced. We are only beginning to see the tip of the iceberg. I want to offer an optimistic note that, even though 1-nanometer or sub-1-nanometer could be challenging, we have a new technological capability using AI to accelerate innovation in science, and that is our part. We have been working on that for many years already. So, of course, it's a fair competition and a solid endeavor. Jeff Su (Head of Investor Relations): Do you have another question about one?
Speaker
Yes. Indeed. I will retire in June, and from now until then is a long time. In the company, a lot can happen. I hope we can definitely execute to C.C.'s forecast for this year. By the middle of this year, I think we can be quite sure we will accomplish that. Of course, C.C. just mentioned that our technology development is on the slew of success. By June this year, we will know what we are to expect in 2025. I set a milestone for our executives. I don't want to share with you, but it's going to be very exciting for TSMC. Of course, from now on, I simply want to encourage our people in TSMC that the world has changed. Just like you mentioned, we must use artificial intelligence for future technologies. So, we will go global, trying to enhance our global footprint and strive for digital excellence. By digital excellence, I mean that we cannot rely exclusively on the hard work of Taiwan engineers; we must recreate our role to tap their talents and bring semiconductor technology engineering to a different level, based on what we already have. Of course, corporate governance is one thing that will always be in my heart. During this transition, I want every executive and our board to adhere to sound corporate governance so that we ensure all process steps abide by our ethical governance rules. Jeff Su (Head of Investor Relations): Thank you, Chairman. Let's take the next two questions from the floor. I think there is one here first: Laura Chen from Citibank.
Speaker
I think we got a lot of discussion about the leading position in the most advanced node. So, I just have a question about your view on the mature node dynamic. In particular, we are seeing that globally, considering geopolitical tension, we are witnessing many fabs being set up around the world. Do you see that, in the longer term, any concerns regarding an industry-wide oversupply? So, what's TSMC's strategy? And also, what's your view on your mature node profitability as well? That's my first part. C. C. Wei (CEO): I think your observation is right. There might be too much capacity being built right now for mature nodes. So, the concern about overcapacity is valid. Now let's talk about TSMC. As I said, TSMC increased the mature node capacity for specialty technology differentiated from others. We work with customers, and that capacity, which we call 'effective capacity', is backed by commitments from customers and future business because we offer value for our customers to design their products. So, we believe that as long as our customers are doing well, TSMC is doing well. And regarding profitability, as I mentioned in my statement, it will hover around the corporate average, so we don't have concerns.
Speaker
That's very helpful. Thank you. Also, my second question is focused on AI-related aspects. As we know, a lot of investors care about your advanced packaging progress. We also know that TSMC has made excellent progress on 3D IC SoIC. So, can you share with us your progress in development beyond CoWoS? What's your plan on the 3D IC and what capacity are you aiming for in the next two to three years? C. C. Wei (CEO): The demand is actually very strong. Today's situation is that we cannot offer enough capacity to support our customers. This condition will likely continue all the way to next year. We are working very hard to increase our capacity; for example, this year we are doubling our output, and still not enough, so we will continue to increase for next year. The progress so far is good because we have invested in advanced packaging technology for more than 10 years already. Hence, we expect the growth rate for CoWoS for 3D IC or for SoIC, per se, to be more than 50% CAGR in the next few years, at least. And we are confident that the demand is there. It's TSMC's capability to offer enough capacity to support our customers.
Speaker
Thank you for taking my question. My question will still revolve around N3 and the IDM. As we understand, the demand is uncertain, but we can increase our business certainty by gaining market share. Do we expect some more contribution or market share gain, especially from the IDM side or any more contribution from the PC side, maybe by the end of the year or anytime soon? C. C. Wei (CEO): That is too specific. You refer to the IDM outsourcing, and I know whom you're talking about, so I better not make any comments. I have stated what I said: we take everything into consideration; we welcome the business, but we're prepared for our capacity expansion. Jeff Su (Head of Investor Relations): Your second question?
Speaker
Yes. It’s on advanced packaging. We know that CoWoS is the mainstream right now—have the management seen clients converting to either CoWoS R, CoWoS L? And then what's the implication for revenue and margin profile? C. C. Wei (CEO): Well, let’s make a joke, I even didn’t know what is called CoWoS R, CoWoS L. But anyway, we are working with customers to support them with adequate capacity, although it's not 100% now, but we do our best. And we're developing that next generation, CoWoS A or something like that for our customer, and it's overwhelming that it is welcomed by all my customers, so we are preparing the capacity for you.
Speaker
Yes, I just want to confirm, C.C., you mentioned that we have a very narrow definition. You call server AI processor contribution and that you said it can be high teens in five years' time because the last time we said low teens. C. C. Wei (CEO): The demand has suddenly increased since last year, I believe around Q1, up to March or April when ChatGPT became popular. So, customers responded quickly and asked TSMC to prepare capacity both in front-end and the back-end, which is why we have confidence that this AI's revenue will increase. We only narrow it down to the AI application processors, by the way. So, we view ourselves as preparing technology and capacity in both our front-end and also our back-end. And it's still in the early stage so far. We already see the growing momentum and we expect, if you guys continue tracking this one, the number will increase. I have confidence to say that, although I don't know how much. Jeff Su (Head of Investor Relations): So high teens, you confirm? C. C. Wei (CEO): Or higher.
Speaker
Thank you so much. The second is about gross margin. In the downturn, we are forming up at much higher utilization than before. Can you talk a little bit about what happens when we get back to close to full utilization? I think we are still running at well below full utilization in 2023. And could you also explain the gross margin dilution that you're expecting in the second half of 2023 because of this capacity conversion. What exactly leads to that gross margin dilution? And is that like a one-time kind of dilution that lasts for a little bit of time and levels off in 2025? Wendell Huang (CFO): Right. In the second half, as I said, there are two negative factors affecting our gross margin this year. The first one is the N3 dilution. N3 volume will be much bigger in the second half than in the first half. So the second half impact from N3 dilution will be between 3 percentage points to 4 percentage points. Additionally, the N5 capacity converted to N3 will mostly occur in the second half as well. That will result in 1 to 2 percentage points. That's for this year. For the longer term, if you look at these two factors, our N3 dilution will gradually reduce because the profitability will continue to improve in the next several years. The N5 converted to N3 is a one-time short-term impact on profitability, which will bring capital efficiency to us in the medium to long term. The benefits together would be much greater than the one-time hit in the short term. If you're talking about the longer-term profitability, including these two factors plus we are selling our value, our technology value, as C.C. mentioned, we continue to drive down the cost. We build our capacity based on the long-term market profile and not the short-term cyclicality, enabling us to have a good utilization.
Speaker
So, just to clarify, given we are at much lower utilization than normal, what you suggest, Wendell, is that gross margin should get back to the mid to high 50s once the upcycle starts to gain more momentum, just like what we saw in 2022. Is that a reasonable expectation? C. C. Wei (CEO): We are working on it. Certainly, we prepare our capacity according to customers' demand. Last year was very challenging because everybody missed their forecast, and so did TSMC, leading to poor utilization rate. I believe everyone will gain more experience in the next few years, and TSMC's utilization rate will continue to increase; I can guarantee that.
Speaker
Okay. Yes. And good luck to both Mark and C.C. as you go through the upcoming transition. I wanted to ask, going back to the question on the IDM, I think earlier you conceded that your competitors’ process is actually pretty good for optimizing to their products. Could you talk about your view on the sustainability of the ramp of that IDM outsourcing with your own products in HPC? If you look out over the next two to three years, do you see that continuing to grow or reversing where there could be a bit of a cooling off from some of the opportunities you have right in front of you now? C. C. Wei (CEO): Randy, that's a good question. Actually, we have taken into account all the considerations, including the IDM capabilities. We have incorporated that into our capacity planning. We implemented a very conservative approach to ramp up our capacity in this kind of situation. I cannot speak more about our strategies.
Speaker
Okay. If I can ask a follow-up on CapEx, earlier you stated the rate of increase will slow down, but I think spending should increase over time as you grow. If you could discuss the CapEx that you guided was flat, should we think of it as a pause where as you start to move into 2-nanometer, there should be another wave of increase? The second part is somewhat related but curious about geographic expansion. There's been a lot of press about new fabs in Japan, the second fab, and potential third advanced fab. And it feels like the first fab went smoothly. Are you starting to redirect or think more expansion to Japan rather than U.S. or potentially both? Wendell Huang (CFO): Okay, Randy. The CapEx dollar amount every year may vary based on different situations. The rate of increase is definitely slower than the past three years. If you look at that differently, the capital intensity in the past three years peaked in 2021 at over 50%, followed by 47%, and 43%. This year, if you do the math, it will average around mid-30s. We expect in the next several years, it will remain in the mid-thirty percentage capital intensity. Jeff Su (Head of Investor Relations): Then, the other part of Randy's question is on geographic expansion. He notes a lot of reports saying we may build a second fab in Japan and we may even build a third. He wants to know if we are redirecting our overseas expansion focus to Japan, or if there indeed is a significant change?
Speaker
No, no. I think the second fab in Japan is in a serious evaluation stage. We haven't announced it to the public yet, and we're still discussing it with the Japanese government. They have been very cooperative, so you may have to wait for that. However, that technology will still be either 7 or 16, 12 technologies. Remember our Kaohsiung fab, the first fab, used to be 28-nanometer or 7-nanometer. Now it's becoming 2-nanometer. If there is a second fab in Japan, that will be our current plan.
Speaker
That's helpful. Quickly on 3-nanometer because 5-nanometer was slightly delayed. Will the 3-nanometers still come two years after the new plan for 5-nanometer in Arizona?
Speaker
Yes. The second fab is under construction. But what technology will be set in that shell is still in negotiation. I think this also depends on how much incentives the U.S. government can provide. Yes, there will be a gap. At least, the current planning has it being set for 2027 or 2028. To be honest, most of the fabs overseas and the technologies being set up are really customer demand decisions at that area at that time. So, nothing is definitive, but we are trying to optimize value for the overseas fabs for TSMC. Jeff Su (Head of Investor Relations): Thank you, Chairman. In the interest of time, we will take the next two from the floor. I think there is one here first: Laura Chen from Citibank.
Speaker
I think we've had a lot of discussion about the leading position in the most advanced node. So, I just have a question about your view on the mature node dynamic. In particular, given the geopolitical tensions around the world, do you see any potential oversupply issue with mature nodes? What is TSMC's strategy? And also, what's your view on your mature node profitability? C. C. Wei (CEO): Your observation is correct; there might be too much capacity being built now for mature nodes. Therefore, concerns regarding overcapacity are legitimate. For TSMC, as I mentioned, we've increased mature node capacity for differentiated specialty technologies as opposed to others. We coordinate closely with customers, and that capacity represents a commitment to future business because we provide real value that enables our customers to design their products. Thus, we remain confident that, as long as our customers thrive, TSMC will as well. Jeff Su (Head of Investor Relations): Thank you, everyone, for your questions and participation. This concludes the Q&A session. We look forward to speaking with you in the next quarter. Goodbye and have a great day.
Need more earnings data?
Explore more earnings information and financial data for TSM
Transcript sourced from Financial Modeling Prep (FMP)